img

img

welcome to Fairmount

When we last reported on the St. Clare’s Monastery site at W Girard & Corinthian Ave., the last vestiges of the building were still standing. In the last month, the facade of the monastery has been taken down and put into storage until new buildings are constructed on the site. Here’s a look at the now empty lot where the monastery once stood.

From the corner

From Girard Ave.

From Corinthian Ave.

We were able to get our hands on the renderings below from YCH Architects, the folks doing the design work for the project. It seems that the developer is keeping his word to reuse the monastery facade, and will be attempting to recreate the look of the adjacent brownstones on Girard Ave. with the new buildings. The development will have thirty units and at least fifteen parking spaces.

Fronting Girard Ave.

Fronting Corinthian Ave.

Seven duplexes will front Corinthian Ave. and eight duplexes will rise in a row directly behind. The fronts of the second row of duplexes will face the backs of the first row. If you’re having trouble picturing it, here’s an aerial view.

Now does it make sense?

As we said, the developer seems to be doing his best to make the new development fit in with the existing buildings on Girard. Here’s another rendering of the new buildings fronting Girard Ave., this time including the two existing buildings immediately to the east.

Looks pretty similar in the rendering

It’s true that many people would have preferred to see the original buildings remain, and it is indeed a shame that they were taken down. But considering the alternative, we’re glad to see the developer making an effort to maintain a somewhat consistent look on the block and reuse an aspect of the buildings that once were. Hopefully, when they’re constructed, the new buildings will look as close to the originals as they do in the renderings.

9
COMMENTS
img
Posted in Fairmount | Tagged , , , , | 9 Comments
  • Mobius75

    wow.. what a wasted opportunity! where do these developers find these bad architects?!!?! Is it because he is the cheapest game in town? Where is the creativity people!?

  • bigD

    I have to disagree with Mobius.  As much as I love modern, even edgy, architecture, it is not always the right choice.  What is shown in the (very preliminary) renderings could be very attractive if it is detailed correctly.  YCH seems to be adapting the elements of the historical buildings that were lost (look at the windows in the first photo) and those of the contextual buildings shown in the last rendering, esp. the paired front doors.  It will all come down to the materials - low quality and/or thoughtless material choices will look like schlock.  Thoughtful choices (though not necessarily expensive ones) will yield an attractive building. 

  • Eldondre

    duplexes? meh.
    indeed, it will come down to materials

  • Muadib

    Developer “keeping his word to re-use the monastery’s face”, really. Where is the existing facade in your photos?

  • http://thisoldcity.com This Old City

    he’s reconstructing the facade. you can see it clearly in the renders… greenish/grey stone work.

  • Omp835

    Wow my heart is un-broken! It looks like they did it right!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=8201023 Scott Gross

    so, we are reconstructing the recently demolished buildings… why, exactly? why not just not have torn them down in the first place? or adapted them? I just don’t get it. What is the fucking point?

  • http://nakedphilly.com/francisville-2/new-girard-ave-bike-shop/ New Girard Ave. Bike Shop Targets Students and Local Residents | NakedPhilly

    [...] multiple projects going on, and a couple more just on the horizon. Plus, two blocks to the west, the thirty-unit development at Girard & Corinthian should be moving forward in the coming months, which will mean even more customers for the bike [...]

  • Irishffq1

    My mother who grew up at 1716 Girard Avenue used to tell me about going to Mass at this monastery.  does this mean tht at some time in the near future kids will be walking from a revitalized area to St. joseph’s Prer only a few blocks away?  Wow,  I never thought it would or could happen, but things are getting closer.

Have a Story for us?
Email Tips@Nakedphilly.com
With Photos & gossip